Every article you’ll find on this subject was written by a recruiter.
That’s not a criticism of recruiters. It’s just worth knowing before you read one, because a recruitment firm’s advice on whether you should hire has the same structural problem as a barber’s advice on whether you need a haircut. They will tell you when to hire, what to look for, how to interview and what to pay. They will never tell you to wait.
I’ve been on the other side of this more times than I can count. I’ve been the agency you’d hire instead. I’ve been the in-house marketer who was somebody’s first marketing hire. And I’ve built marketing teams for clients and then handed them over and walked away.
So here’s the version nobody selling you a candidate is going to write. (If you’re still weighing up agencies and freelancers too, I’ve compared all four ways to get marketing done separately.)
The question behind the question
Almost nobody asks “should I hire a marketer” out of nowhere. It arrives attached to a feeling, and the feeling is usually one of these three:
“I’m spending money on marketing and I can’t see what it’s doing.” You have an agency, or a freelancer, or three of them, and you get a report on the first of the month that you don’t really read because it doesn’t answer the question you actually have.
“Marketing keeps falling over because it’s nobody’s job.” It gets done when somebody remembers. The website has been “nearly finished” since spring. The LinkedIn account posts twice in March and then nothing until August.
“We’re growing and marketing is the bit that isn’t keeping up.” Sales are fine, the product is fine, but the pipeline depends on referrals and you can feel how fragile that is.
These feel like the same problem. They aren’t, and they don’t have the same answer.
The first one is a reporting and ownership problem. Hiring somebody will fix it, but so will insisting on better reporting, and one of those costs £60,000 a year.
The second is a capacity problem, and it’s the one where hiring genuinely tends to be right, but only if there’s enough work to fill a week.
The third is a strategy problem, and hiring into it is the most expensive mistake on this list. If you don’t know what your marketing should be doing, hiring somebody to do it faster just gets you to the wrong place sooner.
Work out which one you’ve got before you write a job description.
When you should hire
Honestly, and without hedging, here’s when I’d tell a client to hire:
When there’s a genuine week’s work, every week, and it’s the same work. Not “there’s loads to do”, because there’s always loads to do. I mean: if you listed the tasks, would they fill five days a week, fifty weeks a year? For most businesses under about £2m the honest answer is no. There are four or five very busy weeks and a lot of quiet ones.
When the work needs somebody inside the business. Some marketing genuinely can’t be outsourced well. If your marketing depends on being in the room when sales talk to customers, on knowing the product properly, on catching the thing someone mentions in the kitchen, that’s an in-house job and no external supplier will do it as well.
When you already know what the strategy is. A first hire is a pair of hands, not a brain-for-hire. If you need somebody to decide what to do, you’re hiring a marketing director, and that’s a different salary and a different search.
When you can manage them. This is the one nobody mentions. A first marketing hire has no team, no manager who understands their work and no peer to check their thinking against. That’s a lonely job and it goes wrong quietly. If nobody in your business can tell whether their work is any good, you’ve hired a person you can’t evaluate.
When you shouldn’t, yet
When you want to save money. You won’t. I’ll show you the numbers in a minute.
When the real problem is that you don’t know what’s working. Fix the measurement first. It’s cheaper, it’s faster, and you might find you don’t have a capacity problem at all.
When you’d be hiring one person to do nine jobs. This is the most common failure I see, and it’s worth being blunt about. Businesses write a job advert asking for strategy, copywriting, design, SEO, paid ads, email, social media, events and the website, and then hire a 26-year-old on £38,000 to do all of it.
Nobody can do all of that well. I do it, and I’ve had sixteen years to learn each piece, and I still bring in specialists for the things that genuinely need one. What you’ll actually get is somebody who’s good at two of the nine, quietly avoids the other seven, and leaves in eighteen months because they were set up to fail.
When you’re hiring because a competitor did. It’s a worse reason than it sounds and more common than anyone admits.
What it actually costs
Here’s where most of these articles stop at the salary figure. The salary is about two thirds of the real number.
UK marketing manager salaries in 2026 typically run £40,000 to £60,000 depending on experience, and most offers for a capable first hire land around the middle of that range. In the South East, London tends to pull salaries towards the upper end.
Let’s take £50,000 and work out what it costs you.
| Year one | Ongoing | |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | £50,000 | £50,000 |
| Employer National Insurance (15% above £5,000) | £6,750 | £6,750 |
| Pension (3% minimum) | £1,500 | £1,500 |
| Recruitment fee (15–20%) | £7,500–10,000 | – |
| Laptop, phone, desk | £1,500 | – |
| Software and tools | £2,000–5,000 | £2,000–5,000 |
| Training | £1,000 | £1,000 |
| Total | £70,250–75,750 | £61,250–64,250 |
So the honest answer to “what does a first marketing hire cost” is about £70,000 in year one and about £62,000 a year after that, for a £50,000 salary.
One saving to check: if your business hasn’t already used its Employment Allowance (£10,500 a year in 2026/27) against other staff, it can cancel out the National Insurance line. Most established businesses with a team have already used it, which is why it stays in the table.
And that’s before the cost that doesn’t appear on any spreadsheet: your time. A first hire needs managing. Realistically two to four hours a week of somebody senior, for the first six months at least. If your time is worth anything, add it.
For comparison, because it’s the comparison you’re actually making: an experienced outsourced marketer at £350 a day costs about £18,000 a year for one day a week, or £36,000 for two. That buys you sixteen years of experience across every discipline instead of one person’s two or three specialisms. But it doesn’t buy you somebody in the building, and it doesn’t scale past about three days a week before you should be hiring anyway.
Neither option is better. They’re better at different things, at different stages.
What to hire first: the generalist trap
If you do hire, the single most important decision is what shape of person you’re looking for, and most businesses get it backwards.
The instinct is to hire a generalist, because you need everything doing. The problem is that a true marketing generalist with real depth costs marketing-director money, and a junior generalist is just someone who is shallow at nine things.
What tends to work better for a first hire:
Hire for the one discipline that drives your revenue, and outsource the rest. If your business lives on inbound search, hire someone genuinely good at content and SEO. If it lives on events and relationships, hire someone who can run events properly. Let them be excellent at the thing that matters and buy in the rest.
Hire for judgement over experience if you’re going to be involved. Someone with three years and good instincts, supported properly, will outperform someone with eight years who’s been coasting.
Write the job description after you’ve written the plan, not before. If you can’t say what this person will spend February doing, you’re not ready to advertise.
Building the team after the first hire
Assuming the first hire works, here’s the order that tends to hold:
One: the doer. Owns delivery of the main channel. Reports to you.
Two: the second discipline, usually design or content, whichever the first hire isn’t. This is the point at which you stop buying that skill externally, and it usually happens somewhere around £3–5m turnover.
Three: the person who owns the plan. Either you promote the first hire, or you bring in a marketing manager above them. This is the hardest transition and the one most businesses fumble, because the first hire often expects to be promoted and often isn’t ready.
Four: specialists. Paid media, CRM, whatever the business now depends on.
Three things to get right whichever order you go in:
Keep buying specialist skills. A three-person team still shouldn’t be running technical SEO or paid media at scale by itself. The team’s job is to own the plan and the brand; some execution should stay external for a long time.
Give them measurement from day one. If you hire a marketer into a business with no analytics and no Search Console, you have hired somebody to work blind and then you’ll judge them on results nobody can see.
Decide who they report to and what good looks like. Write it down. Six months of “we’ll see how it goes” is how good marketers end up leaving.
The third option nobody mentions
There’s a route between outsourcing forever and hiring cold, and almost nobody offers it because it ends with them being unnecessary.
You bring in an experienced marketer, on a few days a month, to do the work and build the thing that replaces them. They run your marketing properly for a year or two, so it’s actually working rather than theoretically planned. Then, when the volume genuinely justifies a hire, they write the job description, sit in on the interviews, train the person they hired, hand over the systems and the reporting and the relationships, and step back.
You get three things you can’t get any other way. You get marketing that works now, rather than a nine-month gap while you recruit. You get a first hire walking into a functioning operation instead of a blank page. And you get someone choosing the hire who has actually done the job, rather than a recruiter matching keywords on a CV.
That’s the model I run. It’s the last stage of how I work: Deep Dive, The Plan, The Doing, then The Handover. The honest sales pitch for it is that the end point is you not needing me.
I’d rather be the person who built your marketing team than the person you’re still paying in 2032.
Common questions
When should a small business hire its first marketer?
Is it cheaper to hire a marketer or use an agency?
What should I pay a first marketing hire in the UK?
Should my first marketing hire be a generalist or a specialist?
What if I hire someone and it doesn’t work out?
Not sure whether you’re at the hiring point yet? That’s a thirty-minute conversation, and I’ll tell you honestly either way, including when the answer is “not yet” or “not me”. Let’s talk. And if your bigger worry is being found at all, start with the free AI visibility checklist.
Last reviewed 25 October 2026: salary range and 2026/27 National Insurance rates checked.



